PIÑON CANYON CONTROVERSY

          The U.S. Army currently occupies a 238,000-acre area south of La Junta, called the Piñon Canyon Military Maneuver Site. Although the Army uses live ammunition on the site, they have made an effort to be a good conservation partner by purchasing conservation easements from willing sellers to protect native grasslands and rare native plants, and to buffer the site from the encroachment of development. Most of the conservation easements have been with local ranchers who continue to own and graze their land. To date, the Army has conserved nearly 10,000 acres, with another 8,000 on the way. A long section of the Purgatoire River flows through the site—juniper-studded bluffs rising above the plains. It is bordered by centennial cattle ranches and the Timpas (northern) unit of Comanche National Grassland.
          Between La Junta and Kim, Highway-109 skirts around the Timpas unit of the Comanche and the Army's land. Signs stating “THIS LAND NOT FOR SALE TO THE ARMY” stand in front of every ranch on the rolling route, passing the turnoff for Vogel and Picketwire Canyons, and across the chocolate Purgatoire River, while gaining elevation to juniper savannah.
          The signs protest the Army's plan to “acquire” an additional 418,000 acres adjacent to the existing land. They claim the acreage is needed to fire long-range weapons and train new troops. When the Army “acquired” land in 1983, they used eminent domain and promised to never shoot live ammo and never increase the size of the maneuver site. Live ammunition is currently used on the site, and now the Army wants more land—promises broken. Rumors abound that the Army really wants 2.5 million acres, essentially all of southeast Colorado, including the Comanche National Grassland.
          This is canyon and cattle country, a land so sparsely populated that parts could qualify as wilderness. Southeast Colorado is defined by extremes—the snowstorms in the winter of 2006-2007 were some of the worst in recorded history, when back-to-back blizzards covered the plains under four feet of snow. Thousands of cattle died. The drought years of 2002 and 2003 brought 3.5 inches of rain total to the area. It is also a fragile landscape at the heart of the '30s dust bowl. Sound grazing practices and good land management prevented the topsoil from blowing away during the recent drought.
          The Comanche is separated into two units, north and south, the Timpas and Corrizo, respectively. Managed by the U.S. Forest Service, the canyons house important archeological sites, pictographs and petroglyphs, and in Picketwire Canyon, the most important dinosaur track site in North America. Native wildlife includes the threatened lesser prairie chicken, large prairie dog ecosystems and associated species, nesting shortgrass prairie songbirds, pronghorn, even roadrunners. Relatively speaking, the area is as important to the shortgrass prairie as Rocky Mountain National Park is to the mountains.
          In a Rocky Mountain News article, local rancher Kevin Karney said, “There's ranchers out there who you could offer any amount of money, and they'll say no.” The unified ranching community has led the way for a complete rejection of the expansion. With no support for the expansion from Colorado legislators, an amendment to a defense appropriations bill denying the Army of money needed to acquire additional Piñon Canyon land was overwhelmingly adopted in Congress. It appears that the Comanche and surrounding private lands have been saved from the indignation of land seizure for now.
          The southeast ranchers will certainly keep a watchful eye on the Army's political maneuvers—we've learned that public land bordering government land is never completely safe.

[BACK]